In lane Book Reviews
A Black Dragon on Red Brings PL Stuart's Drowned Kingdom Saga to a Brooding Midpoint
Description
PL Stuart's sixth Drowned Kingdom novel jumps centuries back, stalls in exposition, then closes on a fierce final act. Our reviewer scores it 7/10.


Some series earn a reader's patience by never slipping. PL Stuart has released a new instalment of The Drowned Kingdom Saga most years since 2021, and A Black Dragon on Red is the sixth of seven planned novels. The reviewer, who has followed the series from the beginning, gives it 7 out of 10. The verdict is mixed but warm: a book with real structural problems that still delivers some of the best writing in the saga.


A story that looks backward
The most interesting choice here is structural. The series has always been told in three parts, and this book keeps that shape, but Stuart uses Parts I and II to travel hundreds of years into Eltnia's past. The Anib have left Acremia, the new kingdoms are rising, and a fresh cast of characters carries most of the early pages. Lord Othrun doesn't appear until about three-quarters of the way through.
That's a bold move for the sixth book in an ongoing series. Established readers lose the easy shorthand they've built up with familiar faces, and the reviewer admits it takes time to care about people who may not survive the chapters they're in. Stuart also avoids spelling out who these people are in advance, so the reveal lands as a gradual pull back of the curtain. Each book in the saga has lifted it a little further, and this one tears it down.
Exposition that tests the reader
Here's the thing: the payoff depends on the setup, and the setup is heavy. Stuart has to cover a great deal of history with a small cast, and much of it arrives through long dialogue passages that grow dense and tangled. The reviewer wishes some of this material had been worked into earlier books. Then again, the reviewer also concedes that doing so would have softened the impact of what this book reveals about Othrun's real position and who his true enemies are.
So Parts I and II feel uneven. Some scenes are gripping, others get buried under information. Readers who prefer momentum may find the early stretch a slog, while those who enjoy patient worldbuilding will likely see the logic behind it.
A hero at his lowest
When Part III arrives, the pace changes sharply. The concluding act moves quickly, and the reviewer found it occasionally hard to keep up. It's also where the emotional core of the book sits. Othrun, a man of action who is usually at his best in a crisis, is shown at a low point. He is no longer the commanding figure who first reached Acremia's shores with the last of the Atalanteans. He's diminished, and the family around him is fractured.
Grief drives much of this section. The loss of a loved one casts a long shadow over the household, and the strain it creates between Othrun and his wife, Sila, is one of the reviewer's highlights. The reviewer singles out how the book shows a relationship souring under tragedy and perceived betrayal, and calls that thread particularly well written. Readers who came for the battles will find them too. The reviewer describes the climax as one of the best-written battle scenes they've read, and the ending is one they didn't see coming.
Where it leaves the saga
The reviewer's honest reading is that Part III is the strongest stretch of the book, largely because it returns to characters they've grown attached to over five previous novels. A Pack of Wolves remains this reviewer's favourite in the series, but this book contains some of Stuart's finest prose. The flaws are visible, yet they don't sink the book, and the reviewer remains impressed by the scale and ambition of the project.
The biggest question stays open. Who is the Black Dragon? Readers will have to wait for Sure-Steel, the seventh and final novel, due in 2027. If the series sticks to its pattern of rewarding patience, that wait may be worth it. The reviewer received an advance copy from the author and notes that the review reflects an honest reading of the book.