In lane Publishing Industry
Sophie Hannah’s No One Would Do What the Lamberts Have Done Turns Mystery into a Playful Puzzle
Description
Sophie Hannah’s odd, self-aware mystery rewards patient readers with shifting perspectives, absurd humour and a slyly ambiguous finish.

Published: 27 July 2025 (print)/20 January 2026 (audio) 
Publisher: Bedford Square Fiction/Bedford Square Publishers & W. F. Howes Ltd
Pages: 406/10 hrs and 59 mins
Narrator: Gabrielle Glaister, Joe Thomas, and Natalie Husdan
Format: Audiobook
Genre: Mystery
★ ★ ★ – 3.5 Stars
You think it will never happen to the ring of the bell, the policeman on the doorstep. What he says traps you in a nightmare that starts with the words, ‘I’m afraid…’
Sally Lambert is also afraid, and desperate enough to consider the unthinkable. Is it really, definitely, impossible to escape from this horror? Maybe not. There’s always something you can do, right?
Of course, no one would ever do this particular something – except the Lamberts, who might have to.
No one has ever gone this far. Until Sally decides that the Lamberts will…
A mystery that asks readers to trust the detour
Sophie Hannah’s No One Would Do What the Lamberts Have Done makes its strangeness part of the reading experience. The book knows its premise is absurd, and it keeps inviting readers to notice that absurdity. For me, that self-awareness gives the novel its particular comic rhythm: it doesn’t try to make every turn feel plausible, because the fun lies in watching the story test the limits of plausibility.
That approach may frustrate readers who expect a more conventional mystery to declare its central crime early. I spent a good stretch wondering when the murder would arrive, and trying to guess where Hannah was steering the story. The answer, when the narrative shifts, isn’t the turn I anticipated. The novel’s detours are deliberate, and its ideas come into focus gradually. A reader who gives it time has more to work with than a reader judging it by its opening stretch.
The reviewer’s experience was that the first part keeps the Lamberts in “on the run” territory, while the later sections change the frame and bring the story’s odd pieces together. The book even plays with the expectations readers bring to that structure. Its commentary on what readers might miss is folded into the novel’s self-conscious style, making patience feel like part of the puzzle.
Absurdity with a purpose
Hannah’s humour depends on the gap between what seems reasonable and what the characters may be driven to do. Sally’s fear and desperation set an unsettling premise in motion, but the book’s tone doesn’t stay within the boundaries of a straightforward suspense story. The result is surreal, frequently baffling and, to this reader, enjoyable precisely because it keeps refusing to settle into the expected shape.
That doesn’t mean every thread receives the neat explanation a mystery reader might want. The reviewer describes potential motives, suspicious characters and possible acts of violence that suggest familiar genre territory, then finds the book carrying attention elsewhere. Those dangling possibilities contribute to the uncertainty: while you’re building one theory, the story has already given you another question to follow.
A recurring complication involves the “Champ debacle” and the need for some “flare,” details that, in the reviewer’s reading, leave important parts of the tale concealed. Hannah’s choices about what to foreground become part of the joke and part of the book’s design. The reviewer finds the resulting shift creative, particularly because the narrative itself acknowledges that its focus is unusual.
Readers who like tidy, steadily signposted clues may find the book a challenge. Those who enjoy fiction that makes a game of its own conventions may be more willing to follow the diversions. The central pleasure isn’t simply working out who might have done what; it’s also trying to understand what kind of story you’re reading and why the narrator has chosen to tell it this way.
A finish that leaves room for doubt
The ending was a highlight for the reviewer. It offers two satisfying ways to look back at the events, while leaving a possible hidden murder hanging in the balance. Clues may support that reading, though coincidence remains possible. The uncertainty lets the conclusion reconnect with the novel’s strange account of a found book without making every element collapse into one definitive answer.
That ambiguity gives the reader a final puzzle to carry away. The reviewer enjoyed tracing theories as the story unfolded, even when those guesses didn’t prove correct. In a more conventional mystery, an abandoned line of inquiry can feel like a loose end; here, the changing perspective and comic misdirection make uncertainty part of the experience.
No One Would Do What the Lamberts Have Done is a better fit for readers prepared to let a mystery wander before it explains itself. The reviewer rates it 3.5 stars and recommends seeing it through: the later shifts and closing suggestions add meaning to a book that can seem baffling if approached with fixed expectations. The audiobook runs 10 hrs and 59 mins, with Gabrielle Glaister, Joe Thomas, and Natalie Husdan narrating. Print publication is listed for 27 July 2025, with audio publication on 20 January 2026.
For readers in the mood for an unusual, self-aware mystery, the practical takeaway is simple: give the Lamberts room to surprise you. The book’s most rewarding questions may be the ones it holds back until the story has changed shape.
You can find No One Would Do What the Lamberts Have Done at these booksellers:
Wordery | Blackwell’s | Angus & Robertson
Fishpond | Amazon | Amazon Aust | Audible
Share this:
- Share on X (Opens in new window)X
- Share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Facebook
- Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)Tumblr
- Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)Email
- Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)Pinterest
- Share on Threads (Opens in new window)Threads
- Share on Bluesky (Opens in new window)Bluesky
- Share on Mastodon (Opens in new window)Mastodon