Skip to the board
Hipmis

In lane Publishing Industry

Two Gentle Halloween Picture Books Turn Witches, Wishes and Monsters into Playful Read-Alouds

LabelPublishing Industry Date AssigneeJanet Dawson

Description

Peggy Archer’s cozy haunted-house tale and Becky Davies’s comic broom adventure offer gentle Halloween reading, with distinct strengths and a few points to weigh.

Two Gentle Halloween Picture Books Turn Witches, Wishes and Monsters into Playful Read-Alouds

For families looking for Halloween picture books with witches and monsters but a gentle feel, Three Little Witches and the Spooky Old House and The Broom of Doom offer two different kinds of fun. Peggy Archer’s story builds a welcoming group scene around tidying an old house; Becky Davies’s sends a frustrated broom through a comic sequence of wishes. Both use familiar Halloween characters without making the scares their main attraction, though their appeal comes from different places.

A dark house gets a warm welcome

Three Little Witches and the Spooky Old House by Peggy Archer, illustrated by Gaia Bordicchia, is published by Little, Brown Books for Young Readers. The 40-page picture book is listed for ages 3–6. Its setting is a lonely, abandoned house at the end of a long, dark road. Three witches arrive with a broom, a sack and a pot, then set about making the place livable: they clean, build a fire and cast spells.

The work brings unexpected company into view. Mice, bugs and ghosts watch from the shadows, and a knock at the door eventually reveals the witches’ friends: an ogre, a mummy and a goblin. The group gathers around the table for popcorn and cider. By the end, the once-unwelcoming house has become a cozy place for a fall get-together.

The reviewer’s response is mixed, but the book has clear strengths for a shared reading. Its repeated phrasing and onomatopoeia give young listeners sounds and patterns to anticipate. Repetition can make a read-aloud easier for preschoolers to join, while sound words invite a reader to give the action extra energy. The reviewer also appreciates Gaia Bordicchia’s illustrations, which help create the book’s spooky setting and cozy destination.

There are reservations, too. The verses seem as if they are meant to rhyme, but the reviewer finds that the effect doesn’t quite land. The story’s arrangement of domestic tasks also raises a concern: the girl witches clean, cook and serve food to male-presenting monster friends. That detail may be worth discussing with children, especially for adults who want Halloween stories to make room for different ways of sharing work. The reviewer’s criticism sits alongside an appreciation for the book’s pictures and its gentle approach to witches, a haunted house and monsters.

A broom gets a turn in the spotlight

In The Broom of Doom, Becky Davies gives the narrator a distinctly comic grievance. Illustrated by Thomas Elliott and published by Union Square Kids, the 40-page book is listed for ages 4–8. The broom opens by insisting, “This is a story about justice…It is not a story about jealousy at all,” a claim that signals the narrator’s self-importance before the story has properly begun.

Tired of being overlooked beside its witch, the broom gets hold of her wish potion and tries to change its standing. It first wishes to become a star, only to find that being one star among many doesn’t make it feel seen. Next it wants fame on the witch’s scale. That wish brings a new problem: people expect the broom to perform spells as well as she does. At last, it asks to return to its old job and feels relieved to be a regular broom again.

The reviewer describes the narrator as cluelessly funny and points to the familiar three-wishes pattern as a useful way to compare this story with other tales. The setup gives children a simple structure to follow: each wish changes the broom’s circumstances, but the result doesn’t match what it hoped for. That makes the book a natural pick for readers who enjoy a character’s comic misjudgments and for adults looking for a conversation about what the broom thought it wanted.

The illustrations take a comic-style approach, which the reviewer thinks will appeal to fans of Dan Santat and Pete Oswald. There’s also a final-page turn that leaves readers wondering whether the story has really finished. The reviewer doesn’t reveal the joke, so it’s best encountered on the page. Readers who enjoy Davies and Elliott’s humor can also find their earlier book, The Mushroom of Doom.

Two different kinds of gentle Halloween fun

These books suit different reading moods. Archer’s story leans on repetition, atmosphere and a welcoming gathering, with illustrations the reviewer especially enjoys. Davies’s leans on a boastful narrator, escalating wishes and a closing joke. For preschool listeners, the first offers repeated sounds and a cozy finish; for children ready to follow a character through a sequence of comic mistakes, the broom’s adventure provides more to track. The reviewer recommends both as non-scary seasonal options, while noting specific concerns and preferences that families can weigh for themselves.

Source: Janet Dawson · kidsbookaday.com

Activity

  1. Card opened by 1,052 readers
  2. Published

Linked cards 3